User talk:Katalina Wulfenbach: Difference between revisions

From Elwiki
No edit summary
No edit summary
 
(4 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
ED Senne:
Hi. I play in the NA server and try to help out occasionally with missing skill info and adding information from the NA server.
I understand your thought behind Diabolic Disaster, really, but it's opening a can of worms we'd rather keep closed.
The moment an external buff that is not inherent to the skill itself is mention, people will start doing the same for other skills. We dont even list Blood Hit on CAv despite that applying no matter what.


If you're going to put "Without buffs" on Diabolic Disaster, be aware that you'll have to do so for practically other skill too to keep it consistent. "Without buffs" is the default for the wiki, so there's no need to mention it.
If you have an issue with me adding info on 2nd job path 3rd class backgrounds from the '''official NA server''', please just edit the page instead of vandalizing my talk page by saying "Do not change the background" and nothing else.


Katalina Wulfenbach:
Thanks!
But then what's the point of putting "lowest Physical Damage of all Hyper Actives in the game" when it does 20,750.6% Physical Damage with [[Bloodlust]]? Isn't that completely misleading???
 
----
It still is, compared to the other hypers on their own, the weakest physical one.
And if you were to include every single buff a class can get on their own, I'd argue it's still pretty subpar.
There's also non-standard buffs that make some hypers functionally more powerful than others, like Add Damage or Maximize (such as IS) or just the fact that some classes have much higher default Attack Power.
 
Again using IS as example, he has, together with Crimson Avenger, the highest base Physical Attack, and his hyper is 16k% buff-less. Demonio in comparison has a much lower base Physical Attack, so even if that hyper did say, 17k% buff-less, chances are it would still be weaker.
 
There's too many factors, which is why we simply put the base % up against eachother: "If the same character with the exact same stats used these skills, one would be more powerful, the other weaker".

Latest revision as of 14:50, 29 January 2018

Hi. I play in the NA server and try to help out occasionally with missing skill info and adding information from the NA server.

If you have an issue with me adding info on 2nd job path 3rd class backgrounds from the official NA server, please just edit the page instead of vandalizing my talk page by saying "Do not change the background" and nothing else.

Thanks!